Wednesday, February 24, 2010

Maazel to Munich?


Lorin Maazel, the former New York Philharmonic music director and maestro of the midsummer Castleton Festival on his estate in Virginia's Rappahannock County, reportedly is about to be named music director of the Munich Philharmonic. (The report comes from Germany's Süddeutscher Zeitung, via Musical America.)

The Munich Philharmonic, once the city's second orchestra (overshadowed by the Bavarian State Radio Orchestra, which Maazel led from 1993-2002), has risen in prominence in recent decades under a succession of stellar conductors: Sergiu Celibidache, James Levine and its current director, Christian Thielemann, who's leaving next year to take over the Saxon State Opera in Dresden.

Great American novel-turned-opera


Composer Jake Heggie, whose "Dead Man Walking" is one of the most compelling operas introduced in the past 20 years, discusses his new "Moby-Dick," as Herman Melville originally titled his novel and Heggie titles the opera, due to premiere in April in Dallas. The composer is interviewed by Bob Clark of Canada's Calgary Herald:

http://www.calgaryherald.com/news/Inside+Calgary+Opera+whale+tale/2601408/story.html

Tuesday, February 23, 2010

Arts Commission shutdown?


The Appropriations Committee of the Virginia House of Delegates voted on Feb. 21 to eliminate the Virginia Commission for the Arts and state grants to cultural entities. Arts groups are mounting a crash campaign to save the commission, which "this year is handing out about $3.9 million in state grant money plus another $1 million in federal funds to 700 grantees," Teresa Annas reports in The Virginian Pilot of Norfolk:

http://hamptonroads.com/2010/02/backers-organize-after-vote-kill-virginia-arts-commission

The budget submitted by Gov. Bob McDonnell proposed cutting the commission's funding by 26 percent, on top of a reduction of about 30 percent made in former Gov. Tim Kaine's administration.

The full House vote on the proposed budget is scheduled for Feb. 25.

UPDATE 1: More from Zachary Reid and Tyler Whitley in the Richmond Times-Dispatch:

http://www2.timesdispatch.com/rtd/news/state_regional/state_regional_govtpolitics/article/ARTS25_20100224-212806/326707/

UPDATE 2: The Roanoke Times' Mike Allen and Tad Dickens count the potential costs to Roanoke and Southwest Virginia from an Arts Commission shutdown:

http://www.roanoke.com/news/roanoke/wb/237813

* * *


For some years, I’ve been conflicted on the question of government support for the arts.

A thriving cultural sphere is integral to a civilized society, and government ought to play a role in maintaining civilization. In this country, that role is fairly recent – the National Endowment for the Arts was established in 1968, and most state arts agencies came into being in the NEA’s wake – and in dollar terms it’s a pretty minor role: The NEA is funded at about $150 million in a multi-trillion-dollar federal budget; most state arts agencies disperse a few pennies per taxpayer.

In exchange for this small-change taxpayer support, arts groups are vulnerable to hostile scrutiny, and occasional harassment, from politicians and interest groups who know little about and care less for creative endeavor. Telling these people what they really should be told – buzz off (or less polite words to that effect) – isn’t possible as long as the arts are subsidized with public funds.

If you believe that creative people should cast a critical eye on society, and especially on those who would impose their "values" on the rest of us, you might reasonably view government subsidy as a means by which hostile forces can constrain and censor creativity – and do so at bargain prices, considering the small sums being given out.

That’s a big-picture view, though.

The more immediate concern is that arts groups are under serious-to-severe financial stress. The recession has ravaged fund-raising and earnings from endowments. Localities have already slashed grants for arts organizations, as well as school arts programs that indirectly benefit them. Sudden elimination of state and federal funding – money from the feds is contingent on money from the state – could push many groups deeper into the red and force some to shut down.

Public funds in various guises account for 5 to 10 percent of the operating budgets of Virginia’s largest arts groups. The percentage is higher, in some cases much higher, for smaller groups and those in rural areas and small towns. They would be the first casualties of an arts commission shutdown; but the fallout would soon hit artists and groups that have benefitted from the commission’s tour program and other "outreach" initiatives.

Saving the Virginia Commission for the Arts is necessary, for both tangible and symbolic reasons. Doing so would head off damage that is way out of proportion to the state money at issue. Saving the commission, however, would be a short-term victory in a conflict that isn’t going away.

Artists and arts groups should wean themselves from taxpayer subsidy, and the ideological pressure that seems inevitably to come with it, as quickly as possible. Any group that remains dependent is poorly managed and faces a painful, perhaps fatal, reality check.

The campaign that Virginia’s arts groups should be mounting (and that would require more than a few days of frenetic activity) is one that mobilizes private support for the idea that creative endeavor yields the immediate benefit of improved academic performance, and the longer-term benefit of laying a foundation for a thriving information-based economy.

These are not airy-fairy notions – they are supported by hard data, from student test scores to the choices that high-tech firms make in locating headquarters and plants – but they present the typical politician with too many dots to connect. The people who need to be convinced, and mobilized, are the corporate and community leaders whom politicians are loth to cross.

Monday, February 22, 2010

Required reading


For those interested in the financial and other challenges facing classical-music organizations, a column by the Philadelphia Inquirer's Peter Dobrin on the woes of the Philadelphia Orchestra, and the readers' comments that follow:

http://www.philly.com/philly/entertainment/84770447.html?viewAll=y

Who needs critics, and what kind?


"In this garbled sensorium we call a culture, criticism is more necessary than ever," Jonathan Jones writes on his blog for The Guardian.

"Real criticism," he goes on, "is not about distinguishing good from bad; it is about distinguishing good from great. There's plenty of terrible art around, but it usually finds its level in the end. The curse of our time, in the arts, is mediocrity and ordinariness" . . .

http://www.guardian.co.uk/artanddesign/jonathanjonesblog/2010/feb/22/critics-need-us

Real criticism is also about distinguishing artistry from personality. Another contemporary curse is that too often we let artists' personal attributes – physical attractiveness, gift of gab, compelling life story – affect our perceptions of their artistic merit. The history of art is full of obnoxious or pathetic characters who produce great art and attractive people who produce junk; and more recent history is peppered with artists who affect a rebellious, anti-social persona to distract from the mediocrity of their art or to make themselves the "work of art."

So, in Jones' "garbled sensorium," maybe the ideal critic would be a cranky old fart (actual age may vary) who is immune to charm, doesn't read publicity packages or listen to talk shows, avoids interaction with the artists being reviewed, and ignores public response.

The blogosphere is an environment in which such critics can thrive.

Sunday, February 21, 2010

Review: Han-Setzer-Finckel trio

Feb. 20, University of Richmond

Reviewed by Francis Church

Franz Schubert’s two piano trios bespeak the glowing joy that marked Richmond’s first preview of spring. The trio of Wu Han, piano; Philip Setzer, violin; and David Finckel, cello, completed the picture on Saturday night with sparkling, balanced performances of the two pieces before a three-quarters-full house at Camp Concert Hall of the University of Richmond's Modlin Arts Center.

The listeners deserve their share of the credit, as well. They had to negotiate a campus gridlocked because of a basketball game. “What will happen when football season arrives?” some asked in pre-concert conversation.

But the rewards came early and often.

First was the pianistic virtuosity of Han. She was quite simply a wonder to see and hear. The music ebbed and flowed with beauty, life and majesty, as the score dictated. Her eyes darted back and forth with her collaborators. We heard none of the banging to which some pianists are inclined in these trios.

Then, there was the cello of Finckel, Han’s husband who shares with her the duties of directors of the Chamber Music Society of Lincoln Center in New York. Not only shunning the facial and physical histrionics of so many of today’s cellists, he simply let the music do the job. His solos in the slow movements of both trios were wonders of lyricism. And he deftly managed the mishap when the hairs of his bow came loose midway in the first movement of the first trio, and he had to halt the proceedings and go backstage for a replacement..

Lastly, Setzer, who is Finckel’s colleague in the Emerson String Quartet, was a bedrock of strength throughout the evening. Occasionally, he was somewhat understated in his expressiveness, but that was to be preferred to overplaying. His dialogue with Finckel in the slow movement of the first piano trio, the one in B-flat major, Op. 99/D. 898, certainly was one of the great moments of the night.

Of the two trios, the second in E-flat major, Op. 100/D. 929, emerged the stronger. The exuberant opening allegro featured the rapturous piano work of Ms. Han; some of the chords were Beethoven-like in their power (Beethoven died in 1827, only a year before the young Schubert died in November 1828 at 31). The cello solo in the andante reminded one of the composer’s earlier song, “Death and the Maiden.” It reappears in the final movement. Is the composer telling us something of his own passing the year after he completed this work?

Occasionally, these trios display the composer’s inclination to write to “heavenly lengths,” as one commentator put it. But in the hands of the Han-Setzer-Finckel trio, they emerged fresh, refreshing and new, as Robert Schumann put it of the first trio: “One glance at Schubert’s trio -- and the troubles of our human existence disappear and all of the world is fresh and bright again.”

After this winter of our discontent and the campus gridlock, we got Schubert’s (and Schumann’s) message.


Francis Church, former music critic of the Richmond News Leader, is a cellist active in orchestral and chamber performance.

Review: Arnaldo Cohen

Feb. 20, Virginia Commonwealth University, Richmond

Scherzo literally translates as “joke;” but as a musical form the scherzo exhibits a variety of humors, from the bumptiousness of Beethoven to the playful traceries of Mendelssohn to the demonic intensity of Bruckner. The four scherzos that Chopin wrote for piano show all those qualities at one point or another, and mask fairly strict classical structure with the italicized phrasing and high sentiments of romanticism. They bring out the rhetorician in a pianist.

Arnaldo Cohen, the Brazilian-born pianist based at Indiana University, made pretty stern work of the Chopin set in this weekend’s installment of VCU's Rennolds Chamber Concerts.


Cohen’s technique emphasized power and clarity; his pacing tended toward the brisk, and dynamism sounded to be a higher priority than rubato in his phrasing. His bright, unsmudged treatment yielded the best outcomes in the central works of the set, the dramatically inflected scherzos in B flat minor, Op. 31, and C sharp minor, Op. 39.

The same qualities prevailed in Cohen’s performance of Busoni’s grand-piano version of the Chaconne from Bach’s Partita No. 2 in D minor, originally for solo violin. Brilliant high notes, emphatic bass and crisp rhythms directed the ear to Bach’s creation rather than Busoni’s elaborations on it.

The pianist devoted the rest of his program to miniatures by Brazilian composers of the early 20th century, only one of whom, Ernesto Nazareth, is well-known outside Brazil. Alberto Nepomuceno’s Air from “Suite Antiga” harkened back to Bach – it proved an apt postscript to the Bach-Busoni Chaconne. Waltzes by Radames Gnattali, Luis Levy and Francisco Braga played on bright tone colors; Levy’s “Valsa Lenta” had a nostalgic undertone more than vaguely recalling Scott Joplin.

Nazareth’s familiar “Odeon” and less familiar “Apanhei-te, Cavaquinho” were characterized by nervy energy and bright coloring, but not much sensuality.