Tuesday, October 20, 2009

Review: Shanghai Quartet

with Lynn Harrell, cello
Oct. 19, University of Richmond

The Shanghai Quartet plays to its strengths when it plays Schubert. This composer’s combination of lyricism and passion, the classicism in his ordering of string voices and the romanticism of his expressive language, the sweetness and storminess, might have been made for these musicians’ techniques and interpretive spirit.

So a program beginning and ending in Schubert – the "Quartettsatz" in C minor of 1820 and the String Quintet in C major, his last work, completed a few weeks before his death in 1828 – made for some of the most memorable, deeply communicative performances in the Shanghai’s 20-year history at the University of Richmond.

The veteran cellist Lynn Harrell joined violinists Weigang Li and Yi-Wen Jiang, violist Honggang Li and cellist Nicholas Tzavaras in the Schubert Quintet, as well as the rarely heard Cello Quintet in A major (1892) of Alexander Glazunov.

Tzavaras and Harrell are both cellists of robust sonority and strong projection. Together, they gave the Schubert bass lines of orchestral scale, almost overpowering the violins and viola in the more extroverted passages of the quintet’s opening movement. Better balances prevailed in the rest of the piece. The musicians played with intense concentration and to mesmerizing effect in the bittersweet adagio, and with both refinement and rustic energy in the scherzo and finale.

Their playing and collective sensibility were at a comparably high level in the Glazunov. The work itself sounds destined to remain a curiosity, an intermittently cloying momento of lyrical late romanticism that takes its sweet time before suggesting its origin. The first movement sounds more like Grieg than like any Russian music of the time; the closest Glazunov gets to sounding Russian – and then, really, more generically Slavic – is in the main theme of the final movement.

Schubert’s "Quartettsatz" is a fitting companion, stylistically and spiritually, to his String Quintet, and the Shanghai played it with the same intense focus and dynamism that the foursome and Harrell would bring to the quintet.

Monday, October 19, 2009

Points to ponder


The Boston Globe's Jeremy Eichler revisits the recent debuts of two new music directors, Alan Gilbert at the New York Philharmonic and Gustavo Dudamel at the Los Angeles Philharmonic, who could represent "compelling models for coaxing the traditional symphony orchestra - essentially a creation of the 19th century - into the future."

Successful 21st-century orchestras must "resist the temptation to cocoon themselves in the narcotic sublimity of their own sound. The fear is always that concert halls in America are becoming citadels isolated from the modern-day intellectual and artistic life of the society at large," Eichler writes:

http://www.boston.com/ae/music/articles/2009/10/18/new_conductors_in_la_ny_pose_a_challenge_to_the_bsos_agenda/?page=1

(Eichler also might have noted the initiatives of an older-school maestro, Riccardo Muti, to nudge the Chicago Symphony into this century with the appointments of Mason Bates and Anna Clyne as resident composers and the launching of several projects aimed at audiences rarely seen in symphony halls.)

How the futures of orchestras and other "high art" institutions will differ from their pasts should be essential points to ponder for the Richmond Symphony committee that will be selecting a new music director around the first of the year, and for the folks in charge of Richmond CenterStage, a venue that has been derided by its critics as a citadel of art forms oblivious to contemporary culture.

Sunday, October 18, 2009

Well-medicated


Jeremy Denk's performances here this weekend remind me to link to his proposed healthcare bill for piano players. Better late (by a month and change) than never:

http://jeremydenk.net/blog/2009/09/10/legislating-from-my-bench/

Dudamel on PBS


Gustavo Dudamel's Disney Hall debut concert with the Los Angeles Philharmonic, including the premiere of John Adams' "City Noir" and a performance of Mahler's First Symphony, will be broadcast on PBS' "Great Performances" at 8 p.m. (Eastern time) Oct. 21, locally on WCVE (Channel 23 [HD1 & 2]).

Pacifica profiled


In The New York Times, Steve Smith profiles the Pacifica Quartet, which is performing on Nov. 7 at Virginia Commonwealth University:

http://www.nytimes.com/2009/10/18/arts/music/18smit.html?ref=music

Saturday, October 17, 2009

Review: Richmond Symphony

Oct. 17, Carpenter Theatre, Richmond CenterStage

Among young musicians generally, and Russian émigrés especially, all roads led to Paris in the early decades of the 20th century. So it’s not too surprising to find the Richmond Symphony presenting a French-accented program with Prokofiev as its centerpiece, or to hear his Piano Concerto No. 3 fit so comfortably between Debussy’s "Prelude to the Afternoon of a Faun" and Berlioz’s "Symphonie fantastique."

Prokofiev sketched this work during an odyssey that took him out of revolutionary Russia, via Siberia and Japan, to the United States; he introduced the concerto in Chicago in 1921. By that time, though, he had settled in Paris, and had absorbed the coloristic and atmospheric language of the French school. (Several generations of it: One hears echoes of Saint-Saëns as well as Ravel.)

In the first of two weekend concerts, pianist Jeremy Denk and conductor Christian Knapp played up the Frenchness of the Prokofiev, emphasizing its wealth of tone colors, bringing a lithe quality to its rhythmic energies and generally giving it a light touch – at least in comparison with the heavy hitting approach so many musicians take with this composer.

Denk played the piano’s many, mostly closely packed notes virtuosically and with nervy energy, but not too loudly, and with ears keenly attuned to the piano’s almost constant interaction with the orchestra. This give-and-take proved especially fruitful in the concerto’s central andantino, but also enhanced the finale, which, for a change, did not sound like a crowd rushing the exit.

Knapp, the eighth of nine candidates auditioning to become the symphony’s next music director, led a "Symphonie fantastique" whose parts often were more impressive than its sum. The performance was not lacking in passion or drama; but the conductor and orchestra seemed intent on rendering its details of orchestration and color as vividly as possible. Digging as deeply into the piece as they did, often moderating tempos to give finer points space and time to be heard, took some of the wildness and headlong momentum out of the piece, but also gave a sharper-than-usual focus to its weirder sound effects.

The long-distance call-and-response of oboist Gustav Highstein in the upper balcony and English horn player Shawn Welk onstage produced the appropriate spatial effect in the early going of "In the Country," and the bass strings sounded prominently, if not lushly, at that movement's lyrical peak. Knapp quite effectively brought out the Beethovenesque soulfulness of this music.

The brass choirs sounded big and brash without overwhelming strings in the "March to the Scaffold" and "Witches’ Sabbath." Berlioz was profligate with percussion in those last two movements of "Symphonie fantastique" – during "March to the Scaffold," he has four players manning two sets of kettle drums, plus bass and snare drummers – and these forces, at their loudest, did overwhelm the rest of the orchestra. The offstage bells in the "Witches’ Sabbath" tended to lag the beat, as well.

Mary Boodell’s beguiling flute solos highlighted the Debussy, which otherwise felt rather brisk. That impression may be due more to Knapp’s energetic conducting than to the tempo he adopted.

More about the acoustics of the renovated Carpenter Theatre (my perspective is from the first row of balcony seats): In this first go at a piano concerto, the instrument, placed near the lip of the stage extension – thus, well into the auditorium – was a strong but not domineering presence. (Denk, though, wasn't playing in alpha-virtuoso mode.) This was a cool evening and many patrons arrived in overcoats, which took some of the edge off the newly brightened sound of the hall, as the acousticians predicted. The space directly under the proscenium arch is indeed an acoustical sweet spot, occupied in these concerts by second violins and violas. Very loud volume does indeed sound congested, and loud percussion effectively blots out everything else.

The program repeats at 3 p.m. Oct. 18 at the Carpenter Theatre, Sixth and Grace streets. Tickets: $17-$72. Details: (800) 927-2787 (Ticketmaster); www.richmondsymphony.com

POSTSCRIPT: French music seems to compel writers to resort to sensory analogy. We’ve all read about the colorful, painterly qualities of Debussy and Ravel (impressionism and all that), and maybe descriptions of music from the preceding generation (Chausson, especially) as fragrant or perfumed. Aside from stray references to tartness (cue the oboe and E-flat clarinet), taste – as in flavor – isn’t normally on this analogy menu. I think it should be, and offer the Prokofiev Third Concerto, at least as Denk played it, as an exemplary dish of what I’ll call foodie French music.

Trying the visual analogy, I don’t hear Prokofiev selecting colors and and ordering them into a coherent composition. (A tidier and more angular version of Jackson Pollack, maybe.) I sense no aroma to speak of in this music. But I sure can taste it. I hear the sound equivalents of the classic five flavors – sweet, sour, salty, bitter and pungent – clearly differentiated ingredients in proper proportions, and courses that let each flavor stand out at some point in the meal.

A lot of French music can be tasted as it’s heard. The later Ravel, such as the Piano Concerto in G major, strikes me as having foodie qualities. I could say the same of many pieces from Les Six, of the generation following Ravel’s, and of a variety of non-French composers who spent time in early 20th-century Paris, from Prokofiev and Bohuslav Martinů to Aaron Copland and Virgil Thomson. (The Americans, though, tend to give you tastes of dust, dew and thin air.) French baroque music, notably Rameau, can be quite flavorful. So can Berlioz, though not in “Symphonie fantastique” unless you have a taste for raw meat.

Cross steps in at Va. Symphony


Robert Cross, the Virginia Symphony's principal percussionist and executive director of the Virginia Arts Festival, has been named interim executive director of the orchestra. The Hampton Roads-based Virginia Symphony hopes to name a permanent replacement for Carla Johnson in its top administrative post early next year, David Nicholson reports in The Daily Press of Newport News:

http://www.dailypress.com/features/family/dp-life_vasymphony_1014oct14,0,3043700.story